Can a Bank Report What It Cannot Measure? The Scope 3 Challenge of MSME Banking

Written by: Patricia Ririsma Saurmaria & Antero Khrisna Anugrah
Designed by: Sarah Aretha J. Tambunan

For decades, sustainability reporting was often treated as separate from financial reporting. Now, that is starting to change. In Indonesia, this change is reflected in the Standar Pengungkapan Keberlanjutan (SPK) developed by the Dewan Standar Keberlanjutan Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia (DSK IAI). PSPK 1 and PSPK 2 were approved on 1 July 2025 and will become effective for annual reporting periods beginning 1 January 2027. PSPK 2 specifically addresses climate-related disclosures and adopts IFRS S2. For the banking industry, PSPK 2 goes beyond emissions from a bank’s own operations. A bank’s climate exposure also comes from the businesses it finances. These financed emissions fall within Scope 3 Category 15, and IFRS S2 contains specific disclosure requirements for commercial banking. This creates a seemingly simple question:
“A bank knows how much it lends. But does it know how much its borrowers emit?”

Consider a bank with millions of business borrowers. It may know each borrower’s loan balance and credit risk, but financed emissions reporting requires different information, such as electricity consumption, fuel use, production activity, and other data needed to estimate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The reporting responsibility sits at the bank level, while much of the underlying information originates from the borrowers themselves. This becomes particularly difficult when those borrowers are micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs). A large corporation may already have an emissions inventory or sustainability systems in place. Still, an MSME may have only electricity bills, fuel purchases, and sales records without ever converting them into GHG data. The Indonesian banking industry has recognized this challenge. In an IAI–PERBANAS forum discussing PSPK 1 and PSPK 2, data availability was identified as a challenge because many borrowers are not yet subject to ESG-related regulation. Then, how is Indonesia’s commercial banking industry responding to this gap?

To understand how this challenge translates into practice, let’s take a look at Bank Rakyat Indonesia (BRI). BRI has already adopted frameworks closely related to the framework underlying PSPK 2. Its loan book is heavily weighted toward MSMEs, which makes it the kind of lender for which the gap between lending data and borrower emissions data is widest. The scale of its MSME-oriented portfolio makes it suitable to answer this challenge. In 2025, BRI reported Rp1.521 trillion in total loans, and 77,49% of it is distributed to finance the MSME. In the same year, BRI reported Scope 3 financed emissions of approximately 12.37 million tCO₂e. Since much of BRI’s Scope 3 emissions comes from its lending and investment activities, the bank disclosed the use of the PCAF methodology, a standardized framework that lets financial institutions measure greenhouse gas emissions to their financing activities. 

PCAF Methodology uses Data Quality Score to provide a way to reflect these differences in measurement quality. The framework ranges from Score 1 to Score 5, with Score 1 representing the highest quality of data and Score 5 the lowest. Score 1 relies on company-reported emissions that have been verified by a third party in accordance with the GHG Protocol. Score 2 can be assigned when unverified emissions data reported by the borrower are available. Score 3 uses other borrower specific physical activity data, such as the volume of products manufactured, combined with relevant emission factors.

When the company doesn’t have specific emissions or physical activity data, PCAF allows financial institutions to use economic proxies. Score 4 relies on the borrower’s revenue and sector specific emission factors expressed per unit of revenue. Score 5 uses sector level emission factors based on assets or revenue combined with sector asset-turnover ratios. These approaches rely heavily on industry averages rather than the individual borrower’s actual emissions data.

This distinction in data quality is relevant to BRI, considering the significant share of MSME financing in its portfolio. Borrowers may have different capacities to report their greenhouse gas emissions. While larger businesses may have established systems to track their environmental impact, smaller businesses may lack the resources or technical capacity to provide detailed emissions data.

For banks, preparing for PSPK 2 goes beyond adding another disclosure to an annual report. A bank that once focused mainly on revenue, cash flow, assets, collateral, and repayment capacity may increasingly need information on electricity consumption, fuel use, production, and other activities of their borrower relevant to emissions. The formal reporting obligation sits with the bank, but the information needed to fulfill it increasingly reaches into the businesses behind that it finance.

The challenge is not simply whether banks can calculate financed emissions. It is whether banks, borrowers, regulators, standard setters, and assurance providers can build an information ecosystem that produces figures that are transparent, comparable, and useful despite unavoidable uncertainty. Because as climate disclosure moves closer to mainstream financial reporting, the quality of a bank’s disclosure may depend not only on what the bank knows about itself, but also on how well it can understand the businesses it finances.

REFERENCES
Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia. (2025a, July 2). DSK IAI sahkan standar pengungkapan keberlanjutan: PSPK 1 dan PSPK 2. https://web.iaiglobal.or.id/Berita-IAI/detail/dsk_iai_sahkan_standar_pengungkapan_keberlanjutan_pspk_1_dan_pspk_2 

Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia. (2025b, March 5). IAI tingkatkan pemahaman standar pengungkapan keberlanjutan pada CFO Forum PERBANAS. https://web.iaiglobal.or.id/Berita-IAI/detail/iai_tingkatkan_pemahaman_standar_pengungkapan_keberlanjutan_pada_cfo_forum_perbanas 

Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials. (2025). The global GHG accounting and reporting standard: Part A: Financed emissions (3rd ed.). https://carbonaccountingfinancials.com/files/standard-launch-2025/PCAF-PartA-2025-Full-Document-Clean.pdf

PT Bank Rakyat Indonesia (Persero) Tbk. (2026a). Annual report 2025. https://www.ir-bri.com/misc/AR/flipbook/AR2025-EN/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *